Detox gets wired into your app. Pie tests the build.

Upload a build and get tests back, with nothing wired into your app. Detox takes native project changes, a testID on each target and a suite your team writes.

Pie

Pie is an agentic testing platform that tests your React Native app from the outside. Upload a build and agents write and run the tests, with nothing added to your project.

Detox

Detox is a free, open-source gray-box framework for React Native apps. Your team writes the tests in JavaScript with Jest and adds a testID to each element they target.

The basics

Pie vs Detox at a glance

PieAgentic testing platform
What it is
An agentic testing platform for web, iOS and Android apps.
Who writes the tests
Pie’s agents explore your app and generate them. Your team adds the cases that matter in plain English.
What a test is
Plain-English steps and checks. No scripts to write, no locators to break.
Where it runs
iOS apps on the iOS Simulator, Android apps on the Android Emulator, and web apps in a browser. Nothing to install.
AI help
The whole product. Agents explore, write and run the tests, and group what they find into issues.
DetoxGray-box framework for React Native
What it is
A free, open-source gray-box testing framework for React Native apps.
Who writes the tests
Your team, in JavaScript, with Jest as the test runner.
What a test is
Jest code that finds each element by a testID your developers add, then taps, types or checks it.
Where it runs
On iOS simulators, Android emulators and attached Android devices that you set up.
AI help
Pilot, which turns plain-English steps into Detox actions with an LLM you supply. Its docs mark it work in progress.
Who brings what

Five jobs in every mobile test. Who does each one?

A working mobile test needs an environment, a script, a device, upkeep and someone to read the failure. Here is who handles each part with Detox, and who handles it with Pie.

The jobDetoxPie
Set up the environment

DetoxYour team adds Detox and Jest, edits the config, and changes the Android project, including Gradle settings, a test file and a network security config.

PieNothing to install. Upload an iOS simulator build or an Android APK.

Write the test

DetoxYour team, in JavaScript. Developers add a unique testID to each element a test touches.

PiePie writes it. Tell Pie Chat what to check, and it explores the flow and drafts the test for your OK.

Supply the device

DetoxYour own simulators and emulators, plus a build of the app for each test configuration.

PieSimulators and emulators for iPhone, iPad and Android phones and tablets, on the OS version you pick.

Keep it passing after a UI change

DetoxYour team updates the tests and the testIDs. A looping animation can stall a run until the app is rebuilt with it mocked.

PieNo locators to repair. Pie re-reads the screen on every run.

Make sense of a failure

DetoxYour team, from Jest’s output. Logs, screenshots and videos are off until you switch them on.

PiePie groups related findings into issues. Your team decides what counts as a bug.

Where they differ

Four reasons to keep test code out of your app.

  1. 01

    Detox asks your app to change

    Detox’s docs say, “This is why you sometimes have to tweak your app specifically for Detox tests.” It also needs native Android edits and a testID on each element a test targets. Pie tests the build you upload, with nothing added to it.

    Source
  2. 02

    The wiring is the cost

    Detox costs nothing to download. The cost is the people who wire it into the app, add the testIDs and repair the tests. In one study, flaky tests alone took at least 2.5% of a team’s productive time. With Pie, your team wires nothing in.

    Source
  3. 03

    Pilot still waits for your steps

    Detox has Pilot, which turns plain-English steps into Detox actions using an LLM your team supplies. Its docs mark it work in progress. Pie’s agents find the flows themselves, with the AI built in.

    Source
  4. 04

    Tested from the screen, like a user

    Pie tests the iOS and Android builds of your React Native app from the screen, the way a user would. The same platform tests your web app too.

Side by side

What changes in your app, and what doesn’t.

Detox goes into your app before it tests it. Pie stays outside.

What you’re comparingPieDetoxAdvantage
Cost to run it No scripts to write and no locators to break, so your team spends those hours on your product. Your team’s hours to wire Detox in, write tests and repair them, plus the machines and CI they run on. Pie
Getting started Upload an iOS simulator build or an Android APK. You get results in hours, not weeks. Add Detox and Jest, edit the config and the native Android project, add testIDs, then build the app for each configuration. Pie
Writing a new test Agents generate tests by exploring your app. Anyone on your team can add one in plain English. Your team writes it in JavaScript, after a developer adds the testIDs it needs. Pie
When the UI changes No locators to update. Pie re-reads the screen on every run. Matchers and testIDs live in code. When one stops matching, someone edits the test or the app. Pie
Apps it covers React Native, native and web apps. Mobile apps run from a build you upload. React Native apps on iOS and Android. Pie
Fixing the bug Pie groups related findings into issues, and can open a Fix PR in a repo you connect. Merging it is always your team’s call. Detox reports pass or fail through Jest. Triage and the fix are your team’s. Pie
License cost Custom pricing, tailored to your team’s requirements and testing volume. Contact Pie for a quote. Free and open source, under the MIT license. Detox
Waiting on the app’s internals Pie works from the outside, on what the screen shows, the way a user does. Detox runs inside the app and waits for network requests, animations and timers to finish before each step. Detox
The exception

When a test must wait on the app’s internals

You want tests that wait on the app’s internals

Detox watches a React Native app’s network requests, animations and timers from inside, and holds each step until the app is idle. Pie works from the screen, the way a user does.

Source
Who should pick which

Which fits your team, Pie or Detox?

Pick Pie to

  • Test your app with nothing added to it.
  • Test your iOS and Android builds on the OS version you pick.
  • Give your team back the hours it spends on testIDs and flaky runs.
  • Run your suites on a schedule or on every new build, with nobody starting them.

Pick Detox if

  • Your tests must wait on the app’s internals, such as timers and network calls.
Getting started

Switch from Detox one flow at a time

No big rewrite. Your Detox tests keep running until Pie covers the same flow.

  1. 1

    Upload a build

    Give Pie an iOS simulator build or an Android APK, or a URL for your web app. If the app has a login, add a test login through a supported path.

  2. 2

    Let Pie explore

    Pie explores your app’s reachable flows and generates tests. You get results in hours, not weeks.

  3. 3

    Add your edge cases

    Type the cases only your team knows into Pie Chat in plain English. Pie explores each flow, drafts the test and runs it once you confirm.

  4. 4

    Retire scripts as Pie covers them

    Compare Pie’s results with your Detox runs, and delete each test once Pie covers the flow.

FAQ

Did we miss a question?
Email us directly →

Is Pie a Detox alternative?

Yes. Pie replaces the tests your team writes and maintains with tests its agents generate by exploring your app.

Stay on Detox if your tests must wait on the app’s internals, such as timers and network calls.

Is Detox free?

Yes. Detox is open source under the MIT license.

The cost is your team’s time to wire it into the app, write the tests and keep them passing, plus the machines and CI the tests run on.

Pie tests the build you upload, so your developers wire nothing in.

Does Detox run on real iPhones?
On iOS, no. Detox doesn’t yet support running on an iOS device, so iOS tests run on simulators. On Android it supports emulators, attached devices and Genymotion Cloud.
What does my team have to change in the app for Detox?

Detox’s setup guide calls for native Android changes, including Gradle settings, a DetoxTest file and a network security config. Its test ID guide asks for a unique testID on each element a test targets.

Pie tests the build you upload, with nothing added to it.

Doesn’t Detox have AI now?

Detox has Pilot, which turns plain-English steps into Detox actions and checks. Your team supplies the LLM, and the docs mark Pilot as work in progress.

A person still decides what to test. Pie’s agents find the flows by exploring your app.

What do Detox users complain about?

Tests that stall while Detox waits for the app. Detox holds each step until the app is idle, and its docs say that design “imposes strictness over the app’s behavior”, so an endless timer or animation can stall a test.

Pie tests your build from the screen, with nothing added to the app.

Does Pie test on real devices?

Real devices are available on demand. Pie runs iOS apps on iOS simulators and Android apps on Android emulators, on the OS version you pick.

Our guide to real devices, emulators and simulators covers which bugs need which.

Does Pie test APIs and accessibility too?

Yes, and both are in beta. Pie runs whole API flows call by call, and checks each screen its tests reach for accessibility problems.

Your UI, API and accessibility testing sit in one place.

How do I move from Detox to Pie?
One flow at a time. Upload a build, let Pie generate tests, and type your edge cases into Pie Chat. Keep your Detox tests running until Pie covers the same flow, then retire them.
Who on my team runs Pie?

Whoever owns quality today, such as a QA lead or an engineer who owns releases. Pie does the exploring, writing and re-running, and the owner decides what matters and what counts as a bug.

Anyone on the team, including a product manager, can read a test or add one in plain English.

What does Pie cost?

Pie’s pricing is custom, tailored to your team’s requirements and testing volume.

You buy one product: agents explore your web, iOS and Android apps, write and run the tests, group related findings into issues and can open a Fix PR.

Book a demo, tell us what you ship and how often you release, and we’ll send you a quote.

Test your React Native app with nothing wired in.

Book a demo and bring the React Native flow your suite keeps stalling on. We’ll show you Pie testing it from the screen.

Sources

  1. Detox docs home. A gray box end-to-end testing framework for mobile apps, built for React Native; tests are written in JavaScript for iOS and Android.wix.github.io/Detox
  2. Detox on GitHub. MIT license; the README lists running on a device as “not yet supported on iOS”.github.com/wix/Detox
  3. Detox project setup. Install Detox and Jest, edit .detoxrc.js, and change the native Android project: Gradle settings, a DetoxTest.java file and a network security config.wix.github.io/Detox/docs/introduction/project-setup
  4. Detox test ID guide. Each element a test targets needs a unique testID, set in the app’s code.wix.github.io/Detox/docs/guide/test-id
  5. Detox, your first test. “This is why you sometimes have to tweak your app specifically for Detox tests.”wix.github.io/Detox/docs/introduction/your-first-test
  6. How Detox works, and synchronization troubleshooting. Detox waits for network requests, main-thread work, layout, timers and animations; looping animations can block a test, with mocking them in a rebuilt app as the workaround. “It imposes strictness over the app’s behavior.”wix.github.io/Detox/docs/articles/how-detox-works · wix.github.io/Detox/docs/troubleshooting/synchronization
  7. Detox device config. Device types are iOS simulators, Android emulators, attached Android devices and Genymotion Cloud.wix.github.io/Detox/docs/config/devices
  8. Detox artifacts config. Logs, screenshots and videos are recorded only when switched on.wix.github.io/Detox/docs/config/artifacts
  9. Pilot-powered Detox testing. An LLM your team supplies turns plain-English steps into Detox actions; marked “Work in Progress”, with APIs subject to change.wix.github.io/Detox/docs/pilot/testing-with-pilot
  10. Cost of Flaky Tests in CI, ICST 2024 industry track. Five years of history, about 30 developers, one commercial project; “at least 2.5% of the productive developer time”. Not specific to Detox.conf.researchr.org/details/icst-2024/icst-2024-industry/1