Most tools run your tests. Pie runs your product.

Hand your testing to Pie’s agents. Take back the hours you spend on scripts. Get a Fix PR to review, not a ticket to triage.

Who does the work
PieMost testing tools
Deciding what to test Pie’s agents explore your app Your team
Writing the tests Pie’s agents Your team writes, records or prompts each one
Platforms Web, iOS and Android in one place Often a tool for each
Fixing the bug Pie can open a Fix PR for your team to review Your team
Teams testing with Pie FiDICK’S Sporting Goods Case studies
Whatever you run today

Your team stops writing the tests

See what moves to Pie’s agents with each kind of tool, and when to stay where you are.

Test frameworks

Playwright · Selenium · Cypress · Appium · Maestro

Stop writing and repairing scripts.

With a framework, your team writes every test and keeps its locators current. Pie’s agents explore your app, write the tests and run them.

Stay on a framework if the license has to be free and your engineers have the hours.

Pie vs Playwright

Device clouds

BrowserStack · Sauce Labs · TestMu AI

Get the tests along with the place to run them.

A device cloud rents you browsers and devices, and the suite is yours to bring. Pie’s agents write and run the tests. Real devices are available on demand.

Stay on a device cloud if you need a wide range of exact device models.

Pie vs BrowserStack

AI and low-code platforms

mabl · Testim · testRigor · Testsigma · Katalon

Start from your running app.

These platforms build each test from a recording, a prompt or a requirement your team supplies. Pie’s agents explore your app and write the tests themselves.

Stay on one if you need desktop, Salesforce or SAP testing.

Pie vs mabl

AI agents and managed QA

QA.tech · Bug0 · Spur · Autosana · Ranger

Keep QA in your own team’s hands.

Some agents run a goal your team writes for each test, and a managed service hands your suite to an outside engineer. Pie is a platform your team runs, and its agents decide what to test.

Pick a managed service if you want someone else to own the suite.

Pie vs QA.tech
Pick your tool

Which tool are you on today?

See what Pie takes over, what your tool costs to run and when to stay on it. Switching happens one flow at a time.

Open-source framework

Playwright

Pick Pie to
  • Ship without writing or reviewing another spec.
  • Rename a button without breaking a locator.
  • Test your iOS and Android apps beside your web app.
What Playwright costs to run

Your team writes each test in code and keeps its locators current. Playwright’s agents can draft a spec, and your team still reviews it.

When to stay

Playwright’s license is free. Stay if your engineers have the hours to write and maintain every spec.

Open-source framework

Selenium

Pick Pie to
  • Drop the page objects, the explicit waits and the Grid.
  • Get tests your whole team can read, in plain English.
  • Cover native apps without a second framework.
What Selenium costs to run

Your team writes the tests in code, structures them with page objects and explicit waits, and hosts the Grid to run them in parallel.

When to stay

Selenium costs nothing to license. Stay if your team has the engineers to build and run the suite around it.

Open-source framework

Cypress

Pick Pie to
  • Test the flows nobody found time to script.
  • Reach the app on your users’ phones, past the browser.
  • Have a pull request tested before it merges.
What Cypress costs to run

Your team writes each spec in JavaScript or TypeScript and keeps its selectors current as the app changes.

When to stay

The Cypress app is free. Stay if your developers have the time to script each flow.

Open-source framework

Puppeteer

Pick Pie to
  • Get the tests, the runs and the reports with nothing to assemble.
  • Find the flows no script covers.
  • Test native iOS and Android apps, not a phone-sized browser.
What Puppeteer costs to run

Puppeteer controls the browser and leaves the rest to you. Your team picks a test runner and assertions, writes each script and keeps its selectors current.

When to stay

Stay on Puppeteer if the job is browser automation, such as PDFs, crawling or Chrome internals, more than testing.

Open-source framework

WebdriverIO

Pick Pie to
  • Stop maintaining specs and page objects.
  • Skip the Appium setup for mobile.
  • Let agents decide what to check, as well as drive the browser.
What WebdriverIO costs to run

Your team writes each spec in JavaScript or TypeScript, maintains the page objects behind it, and brings the machines or the cloud to run it on.

When to stay

Stay on WebdriverIO if you test desktop apps such as Electron or Tauri.

Mobile framework

Appium

Pick Pie to
  • Get a first result from a build, with no server or drivers to set up.
  • Run iOS and Android tests on your schedule, with nobody starting them.
  • Test your web app on the same platform.
What Appium costs to run

Your team sets up the drivers, devices and simulators, including a Mac with Xcode for real iOS devices, then writes each test and keeps its locators current.

When to stay

Stay on Appium if you test beyond phones and tablets, or your bugs depend on hardware you own.

Mobile framework

Maestro

Pick Pie to
  • Stop editing YAML each time a screen changes.
  • Give your whole team tests it can read.
  • Test your web app as well as your mobile apps.
What Maestro costs to run

Your team writes each flow in YAML and updates it when a screen changes. Runs happen on emulators and simulators you set up, or on Maestro Cloud.

When to stay

The Maestro CLI is free. Stay if your team has the time to write a flow for every journey.

Mobile framework

Espresso

Pick Pie to
  • Take test writing off your Android developers.
  • Let anyone on your team add a test in plain English.
  • Cover iOS and web alongside Android.
What Espresso costs to run

Your Android developers write each test in Kotlin or Java and keep its view IDs current as the app changes.

When to stay

Stay on Espresso if your developers need fast tests that run inside the app’s own process.

Mobile framework

XCUITest

Pick Pie to
  • Get iOS tests with no Swift to write.
  • Run on iPhone and iPad simulators, on the iOS version you pick.
  • Cover Android and web in the same place.
What XCUITest costs to run

Your iOS developers write each test in Swift and run it on a Mac, against simulators and devices or on Xcode Cloud.

When to stay

Stay on XCUITest if you test Apple Watch, Apple TV or Mac apps.

Mobile framework

Detox

Pick Pie to
  • Test your React Native app with nothing wired into it.
  • Skip adding a testID to every element.
  • Test from the screen, the way a user does.
What Detox costs to run

Your developers add a testID to each element, write the tests in JavaScript with Jest, and set up the simulators and emulators to run them.

When to stay

Stay on Detox if your tests must wait on the app’s internals, such as timers and network calls.

Device cloud

BrowserStack

Pick Pie to
  • Get the tests along with somewhere to run them.
  • Start with no suite at all.
  • Stop healing locators, because there are none.
What BrowserStack costs to run

BrowserStack gives you devices and browsers to run on. Your team decides what to test, writes the scripts and keeps them passing.

When to stay

Stay on BrowserStack if your bugs live on one exact phone or browser version.

Device cloud

Sauce Labs

Pick Pie to
  • Have the tests written, run and re-run on the schedule you set.
  • Cover most flows without a device lab.
  • Get a Fix PR to review for the bug a run finds.
What Sauce Labs costs to run

Sauce Labs runs your scripts on virtual and real devices. The scripts are yours to write and keep passing.

When to stay

Stay on Sauce Labs if a bug only shows on one exact device model or browser version.

Device cloud

TestMu AI

Pick Pie to
  • Make adding your app the first step, not writing a script.
  • Have agents choose what to test, without waiting for a prompt.
  • End up with a suite your team never had to write.
What TestMu AI costs to run

TestMu AI gives you browsers and devices to run on. Your team brings the tests, in Selenium, Playwright, Cypress or Appium, and maintains them.

When to stay

Stay on TestMu AI if you need to reproduce a bug on one specific device or browser build.

AI testing platform

mabl

Pick Pie to
  • Get tests before you record anything.
  • Cover web, iOS and Android from the first run.
  • See a failure arrive with a proposed fix.
How Pie differs from mabl

mabl builds each test from a recording or a prompt your team makes. Pie’s agents explore your app and write the tests with nothing to record first, on web, iOS and Android.

When to stay

Stay on mabl if you need performance testing, or runs across four browsers.

AI testing platform

Testim

Pick Pie to
  • Get tests nobody had to record.
  • Run one mobile test across devices.
  • Work with no locators to heal.
How Pie differs from Testim

Testim starts from a test someone records in its browser extension. Pie starts from your running app: its agents explore the reachable flows and write the tests.

When to stay

Stay on Testim if you test Salesforce apps.

AI testing platform

testRigor

Pick Pie to
  • Go from a failed test to a Fix PR.
  • See one issue per bug, not one per failed test.
  • Keep suites running with nobody starting them.
How Pie differs from testRigor

With testRigor, your team writes each test in plain English and edits the sentence when a flow changes. Pie’s agents write the tests from your running app.

When to stay

Stay on testRigor if you test Windows desktop or mainframe apps.

AI testing platform

Testsigma

Pick Pie to
  • Start from your running app, with no requirement to write up.
  • Skip approving a plan before the first run.
  • Follow a failed test through to a Fix PR.
How Pie differs from Testsigma

Testsigma’s agents work from your requirements, and a person approves each plan. Pie’s agents work from your running app, with nothing to write up first.

When to stay

Stay on Testsigma if you test Salesforce, SAP or Windows desktop apps.

AI testing platform

Katalon

Pick Pie to
  • Get tests without a tester working a recorder.
  • Leave no locators to heal or approve.
  • Explore, write, run and report in one place.
How Pie differs from Katalon

Katalon is a desktop IDE where your testers build each test. Pie’s agents explore your app, write the tests and run them.

When to stay

Stay on Katalon if you test Windows desktop apps.

AI QA agent

QA.tech

Pick Pie to
  • Test iOS and Android from the start.
  • See one issue where twenty tests failed.
  • Get a Fix PR, not just a ticket.
How Pie differs from QA.tech

QA.tech runs a goal you describe for each test. Pie’s agents explore your app and write the tests themselves, then group what they find into issues.

When to stay

Stay on QA.tech if you only ship a web app and it already covers it.

AI QA agent

Bug0

Pick Pie to
  • Add a test yourself, any time.
  • Cover iOS and Android beside your web app.
  • Receive findings with a fix to review.
How Pie differs from Bug0

Bug0 is a managed service for web apps, run by a named engineer. Pie is a platform your own team runs, across web, iOS and Android.

When to stay

Stay on Bug0 if you want a managed service to run QA for your web app.

AI QA agent

Rainforest QA

Pick Pie to
  • Automate iOS and Android tests, not only web.
  • Add a test by describing it.
  • Have a Fix PR opened after a finding.
How Pie differs from Rainforest QA

Rainforest QA’s AI drafts a no-code test and your team finishes it in a visual editor. Pie’s agents write and run the tests on web, iOS and Android.

When to stay

Stay on Rainforest QA if you need older browsers such as Internet Explorer 11, or human testers on call.

AI QA agent

Ranger

Pick Pie to
  • Test the whole app you ship, on web, iOS and Android.
  • Check a change against the flows around it.
  • Let a product manager edit a test’s steps.
How Pie differs from Ranger

Ranger checks the feature your coding agent is building, on your machine. Pie tests your whole app across web, iOS and Android, and groups what it finds into issues.

When to stay

Stay on Ranger if you want a coding agent’s work checked on localhost as it builds.

AI QA agent

Autosana

Pick Pie to
  • Get tests before anyone writes a flow.
  • Add a check without a new flow file.
  • Have a Fix PR opened for what the tests find.
How Pie differs from Autosana

With Autosana, your team writes a natural-language flow for each test. Pie’s agents explore your app and write the tests, then can open a Fix PR for what they find.

When to stay

Stay on Autosana if you need runs across Chrome, Firefox and Edge.

AI QA agent

Spur

Pick Pie to
  • Let agents decide what to test.
  • See failures sorted into issues.
  • Add your edge cases in Pie Chat.
How Pie differs from Spur

Spur runs the intents your team writes, one for each test. Pie decides what to test by exploring your app, then writes and runs the tests.

When to stay

Stay on Spur if you need localization testing, or runs across four browsers.

AI QA agent

MobileBoost

Pick Pie to
  • Get mobile tests from your build, not a prompt.
  • Pick the OS version for iPhone, iPad and Android runs.
  • Test your web app in the same place when you need it.
How Pie differs from MobileBoost

MobileBoost’s GPT Driver runs the mobile tests your team describes. Pie’s agents explore your iOS and Android builds and write the tests.

When to stay

Stay on MobileBoost if you want tests to run on your own BrowserStack or Sauce Labs account.

The classic

A spreadsheet of test cases

Pick Pie to
  • Give the person who keeps the sheet their release days back.
  • Turn the rows that matter into tests, typed into Pie Chat in plain English.
  • Test web, iOS and Android apps from one place.
What the spreadsheet costs to run

The sheet is free. The bill arrives on release day, when someone clicks through every row by hand.

When to stay

Stay on the spreadsheet if your app is small, releases are rare, and the person who keeps it knows every corner of the product. It’s free, everyone can open it, and it has never once flaked.

Coding agent

Claude or another coding agent

Pick Pie to
  • Get tests nobody had to prompt for, one at a time.
  • Have them run on a schedule or on every new build, with nobody starting them.
  • Read what broke as an issue, not a diff to review.
What a coding agent costs to run

The agent writes test code when you ask for it. Your team still prompts for each test, reviews the code, runs it and repairs it when the app changes.

When to stay

Stay with a coding agent if your team wants its tests as code in its own repository, and has the hours to prompt for them, review them and keep them passing.

In-house framework

A framework you built in-house

Pick Pie to
  • Put the engineers who maintain the framework back on your product.
  • Get a new flow tested without a ticket to the framework’s owners.
  • Add iOS and Android without building a second harness.
What your own framework costs to run

Nobody invoices you for it. The bill is the engineers who keep it running, and the tests that wait when they’re busy.

When to stay

Stay on your own framework if it tests something particular to your product, such as hardware or a custom protocol, and a team is funded to maintain it.

Before you book

Will it fit?

Know what Pie needs before the first call.

What you send

A URL for a web app. For mobile, an iOS simulator build or an Android APK.

How Pie works

What Pie needs

A test login through a supported path, if your app has one. To test pull requests, a preview URL or a build upload for each change.

Integrations

Security

Pie has a SOC 2 Type 2 report, and the most recent one is available on request. Data is encrypted in transit. We never use your source code, meaning the files and code changes in your repositories, to train AI models.

Security at Pie
Every comparison

Grouped by the kind of tool you run

Open your category for the Pie vs pages, then the head-to-heads, alternatives lists and guides that go deeper.

Web frameworks 19 comparisons
Mobile 17 comparisons
Device clouds 7 comparisons
AI and low-code platforms 23 comparisons
Testing approaches 5 guides

FAQ

Did we miss a question?
Email us directly →

Does Pie replace Selenium, Playwright or Cypress?

Yes. Pie replaces the end-to-end scripts your team writes and maintains with tests its agents generate by exploring your app.

Stay on a framework if you want every test as code in your repo, or a handful of scripts covers your app. Your unit and component tests stay where they are.

What does a free testing framework really cost?

The license is free. The running cost is your team’s hours to write, review and repair tests, plus the CI to run them.

A study at ICST 2024 of one commercial project, with about 30 developers and five years of history, found flaky tests alone took “at least 2.5% of the productive developer time”.

Half the organizations in the World Quality Report 2025-26 name maintenance burden and flaky scripts as a test automation challenge.

Does Pie test on real devices?

Real devices are available on demand. Pie runs iOS apps on iOS simulators and Android apps on Android emulators, on the OS version you pick, and web apps in a browser.

A device cloud such as BrowserStack or Sauce Labs lists the wider range of exact models.

How is Pie different from other AI testing tools?

Pie starts from your app, with no recording, prompt or requirement to write first. It explores the reachable flows, writes the tests and groups what it finds into issues.

Pie can then open a Fix PR with a proposed fix in a repo you connect, and merging it is always your team’s call.

How do I move to Pie?
One flow at a time. Pie explores your app and generates tests, and your team adds its edge cases in plain English in Pie Chat. Keep your scripts running until Pie covers the same flow, then retire them.
Who on my team runs Pie?

Whoever owns quality today, such as a QA lead or an engineer who owns releases. Pie does the exploring, writing and re-running, and the owner decides what matters and what counts as a bug.

Anyone on the team can read a test or add one in plain English.

What does Pie cost?

Pie’s pricing is custom, tailored to your team’s requirements and testing volume.

You buy one product: agents explore your web, iOS and Android apps, write and run the tests, group related findings into issues and can open a Fix PR.

Book a demo, tell us what you ship and how often you release, and we’ll send you a quote.

Retire the tests your team keeps repairing.

Book a demo and tell us what you run today. We’ll show you which tests Pie would take over, and how to switch one flow at a time.

Sources

  1. Tests as code in your repository; TypeScript, Python, .NET and Javaplaywright.dev · github.com/microsoft/playwright
  2. “Write your scripts in Java, Python, C#, Ruby, JavaScript or Kotlin using the official W3C WebDriver standard”selenium.dev
  3. “The Cypress App is free and open source”; “Run your suite in a real browser, rewind any failure”cypress.io
  4. One API for web, mobile and desktop apps; MIT license with no paid tier and no vendor; tests in JavaScript or TypeScriptwebdriver.io/docs/why-webdriverio · github.com/webdriverio/webdriverio
  5. “a JavaScript library which provides a high-level API to control Chrome or Firefox”; listed uses include screenshots and PDFs, crawling and testing Chrome extensionspptr.dev/guides/what-is-puppeteer · pptr.dev/guides/chrome-extensions
  6. “an open-source project and ecosystem of related software, designed to facilitate UI automation”; automation code written through a client library for your languageappium.io/docs/en/latest · /intro
  7. Local plan free and open source, under the Apache 2.0 license; flows are YAML files with an appId and a list of commandsmaestro.dev/pricing · github.com/mobile-dev-inc/Maestro
  8. Google’s UI test framework for Android, with tests in Kotlin or Java; synchronizes with the main thread; Apache 2.0 licensedeveloper.android.com/training/testing/espresso · github.com/android/android-test
  9. Apple’s UI automation framework, used with XCTest inside the Xcode project; covers iOS, iPadOS, macOS, watchOS and tvOSdeveloper.apple.com/documentation/xcuiautomation
  10. A gray box end-to-end testing framework for mobile apps, built for React Native; tests are written in JavaScript; device types include attached Android devicesgithub.com/wix/Detox · wix.github.io/Detox/docs/config/devices
  11. “30,000+ real iOS & Android devices”; “Scale your Selenium, Playwright, Cypress and other automation tests”browserstack.com · browserstack.com/automate
  12. “Reproduce reported bugs on the exact real device they hit it on”saucelabs.com
  13. “50,000+ real iOS and Android devices”, as stated by TestMu AI, formerly LambdaTest; runs Selenium, Playwright, Cypress and Appium suites; live testing from $15 a monthtestmuai.com/real-device-cloud · testmuai.com/pricing
  14. “mabl agents continuously validate customer experiences across web, mobile, and APIs”; “Import Postman collections”mabl.com
  15. “AI-powered testing for custom web, mobile, and Salesforce apps”; custom JavaScript steps in the visual editor; a free Community plan after the trialtestim.io · docs.tricentis.com/testim/content/administration/subscription-plans/index.htm
  16. “use free-flowing plain English to build test automation”; native and hybrid iOS and Android, native Windows, APIstestrigor.com
  17. “lets manual testers and QA analysts automate without writing scripts”; web, mobile, API, desktop, Salesforce and SAPtestsigma.com
  18. “Author web, mobile, API and desktop tests with no-code, low-code or full code”katalon.com
  19. Cost of Flaky Tests in CI, ICST 2024 industry track. Five years of history, about 30 developers, one commercial project; “at least 2.5% of the productive developer time”. Not specific to any framework.conf.researchr.org/details/icst-2024/icst-2024-industry/1/Cost-of-Flaky-Tests-in-CI-An-Industrial-Case-Study
  20. World Quality Report 2025-26 (Capgemini, Sogeti, OpenText), Fig 15. 50% cite maintenance burden and flaky scripts as a test automation challenge.capgemini.com/insights/research-library/world-quality-report-2025-26